Pages

Saturday, December 28, 2024

The Top 10 Albums Most Mistaken for Metal in 2024







Once upon a time, the battle cry championed by metal bands was "Death to False Metal", it's a sentiment going back to the earliest beginnings of the genre when it drew lines to separate itself from the bands of the Sunset Strip who wanted the look but were making glammed out pop music. Today kids are thin-skinned and take offense screaming out that this is gatekeeping rather than seeing it as quality control standards. Most of those people just need to feel like they belong wherever they want to go and call those who actually belong there elitists as a projection of their own insecurities. 

I'm here to say fuck your feelings. In the interest of this blog's mission statement pledging to always tell it like it is easy even if you can't handle the truth. After seeing albums like those represented here appearing on metal top ten lists, I think it fair to set the record straight and have some truth in advertising to pick out the top ten offenders in this regard. Four of these entries are great albums, they just are not great metal albums. They are great rock, shoe-gaze, and trip-hop albums, just not metal. There are a few that are terrible, but they are also not metal so here we go setting the record straight for you.  




 10- Unto Others - "Never Neverland" 

These guys used to make cock rock dressed up as goth, but now they are applying that template to pop music, it's catchier than their previous work, Wish it was darker than it is. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/08/unto-others-never-neverland.html


9-Haunted Plasma -"I' 

This album features members of Oranassi Pazuzu, but that doesn't make it metal. It does carry a great dark throb to it and has Mat McNeary lending his voice to this album, so it sometimes sounds like Grave Pleasures on acid. Lots of metal comes from Finland, this project is not counted among that. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/04/haunted-plasma-i.html


8-Dool- "The Shape of Fluidity" 

There were once doom metal elements to what they did on their previous album. This more rock n roll approach to things works as they are appearing on more end-of-the-year lists, which means they are getting more recognition, which works for me, as they deserve it even if they are growing away from metal. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/05/dool-shape-of-fluidity.html


7-Bring me the Horizon - ""Post Human -NeX GEn" 

This is a fun pop album, Pierce the Veul might do it better, but kids seem to like this, though kids don't know any better as they are young and dumb, we know better, making it our job to set the record straight, distortion or the occasional scream does not make things metal, even pop bands throw temper tantrums from time to time. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/05/bring-me-horizon-post-human-nex-gen.html


6-Devin Townsend- "Powernerd" 

Here is a good case in point of an artist who was in a metal band (Strapping Young Lad) branching off to play other kinds of music, Sure the influence of their metal past is there, but that does not make their current project metal. What this album proves is Def Leppard would be fools for not asking Devy to produce their next album as he sounds more like them than they have in decades. If you are tempted to say Def Leppard is metal then you should keep your mouth shut before you embarrass yourself. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/11/devin-townsend-powernerd.html


5-Pallbearer - "Mind Burns Alive" 


It was not so long ago these guys were a doom-metal band. People change and artists grow out of genres and do other things, I can accept that. These guys made one of the year's best shoe-gaze albums, so at least if they are no longer a metal band they are good at what they are doing. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/04/pallbearer-mind-burns-alive.html

 

4-Zeal & Ardor-"Grief" 

This one made it onto my worst albums of 2024 list. This project has a long history of being mislabeled thanks to the wishful thinking of the music press. They were first called black metal when they had more in common with ni-metal, and now they are just a shitty rock band who might as well be Breaking Benjamin or some other radio shit. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/08/zeal-ardor-grief.html


3-Poppy-"Negative Spaces" 

I like this album, and while Poppy has appropriated metal in the past, this album kind of splits the difference between her flirtations with nu-metal and the pop of her previous album. There is a mainstream radio rock formula on most of these songs that she makes work thanks to her quirky charisma. I think the guest appearance she did with Knocked Loose this year has made people unable to compartmentalize her from her own career, but this is not a metal album, industrial-influenced pop at best. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/11/poppy-negative-spaces.html


2-Linkin Park -"From Zero"


Lumped in with nu-metal, but they have never been a metal band. This album brings that fact to the forefront. It's not a bad album though unable to live up to its hype, this is a fun lighthearted pop album that its fans are taking way too seriously. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/11/linkin-park-from-zero.html


1-Chelsea Wolfe -" She Reaches Out To She Reaches Out To She"


She's never made a metal album, there are albums where that is used as a dynamic in a few songs, but never throughout. This is more of a trip-hop album it is closer to Portishead than Motorhead, and yet it keeps appearing on metal lists because people are well ...stupid. I prefer the acoustic episode to this one , as it sounds more like her, but it continues to grow on me.  Regardless of how good it is, if you think this is metal, you clearly don't know what you are talking about. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/02/chelsea-wolfe-she-reaches-out-to-she.html


pst660

Thursday, December 26, 2024

ILS : "To End Is To Begin"

 



Continuing my streak of reviewing albums my peers in the inner webs chose as their number one picks, this one is coming from Dead Air at the Pulpit, whose list shared some common ground with mine. This album is like an angrier less hip version of Chat Pile with more explosive vocals. They lean more toward noise rock than sludge. The first track is cool, and the second song finds the vocals talking through it a little more. However, the screamed vocals do need something to contrast them. By the time we get to "Don't Try Me" it's clear some of these songs sound the same with this formula, as I thought I was on the third, not the fourth song. 

"Fallen" the more punk-spoken vocal is the main narrative where the screaming is relegated to the periphery.  Works well enough, but when you compare it to a band like Glassing or Crippling Alcoholism falls short from a songwriting perspective. They catch onto the slinkier Tool groove, with palm-muted guitars by the time we get to "Sate". It's darker so I appreciate that. This carries over into the song after, though to a lesser extent. They are back to business as usual for  "Hail Mary" which is angular the vocals play less of an intentional role and feel more incidental. 

There is more redneck speculation to the punk lumber of "Let the Blood Pour Out" . The last song stomps with more of a punk feel than metal, as it has a purpose but still carries wreckless abandon in its veins. I'll give this album an 8.5, as it's fun. I could stand to have more dynamic vocals, but that is my personal preference, I think these guys made the album they set out to make, even if it is not the most original thing I have heard this year. 




pst659

The Top 10 Most Disappointing Albums of 2024









Here's a new edition to the end-of-the-year traditions that makes more sense this year than in the past. I've already warned you there would be end-of-the-year lists not only with perhaps albums from my worst-off list but also trying to make a bigger deal out of albums that are more hype than substance for various reasons we can see here, ranging from nostalgia to wanting to offer a diverse or inclusive list rather than just focusing on which albums have the best songs. People live in such a warped reality bubble they can not handle disappointment and would rather pretend the emperor is wearing clothes than admit their favorite artists are falling short. My role has always been to call out things for what they are, as a form of quality. These are not bad albums, but they did not live up to what these artists did in the past, except for one entry that improved but was never that great and got a critical pass from mainstream music media for reasons that have nothing to do with music.  There are only three artists  that are favorites of mine that missing the mark stung a bit, but in the interest of honest journalism those are the ones I must draw the most attention to so here are the top 10 Most Disappointing albums of 2024


10- Tribulation - ''Sub Rosa In Æternum"

This album is an honorable mention, as it's not bad. It's decent for what is it, in fact in my original review I gave it a 9, but the more I listen to it the more lackluster it feels, some of the gloom is more genuine than others, I think the fact they have strayed so far from their death metal beginnings is part of the problem here, if I reviewed this album today it would have gotten an 8, which would not make it contender for any top 10 lists, aside from this one since this band is capable of greatness. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/10/gothtober-tribulation-sub-rosa-in-ternum.html


9-Dool- "The Shape of Fluidity" 


Another case of a band whose previous work was certainly better. This one scored an 8, on my initial listen, which still put it ahead of most radio rock, but unlike their previous album failed to inspire me to give additional listens , so if I had to rate it today would give it a 7.5, a far cry from a top 10 contender. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/05/dool-shape-of-fluidity.html


8-Body Count- "Merciless" 


This is a band that was never any good, and this album is actually an improvement. At least that is what I thought upon listening to the first few songs then it got worse the deeper into the album you go. I don't care how much they paid David Gilmore to be on this album it's the worst cover of "Comfortably Numb" I've heard. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/11/body-count-merciless.html


7-Oranssi Pazuzu : "Muuntautuja" 

In my review of this album, I first said they must be growing killer shrooms in Finland. It's a drugged-out mess of an album that captures cool sounds, they never are woven into being cool songs.  They have proven they can balance the two and it's not the case here. If I had to review this one today I would have given it a 7, clearly not best of material. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/10/oranssi-pazuzu-muuntautuja.html


6-Linkin Park- "From Zero" 

This one is more of a matter of all the hype and buzz around it, there was no way it could live up to the hype, it also highlighted the fact that Linkin Park has always been a pop band despite getting lumped into nu-metal. A few catchy pop songs do not equate to the best of 2024 material. 

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/11/linkin-park-from-zero.html


5-Oceans of Slumber - 'Where Gods Fear to Speak" 

Their previous material was doomier and made better use of her soulful voice, this feels rushed and uninspired, well-produced but also very bland. If you think this is the best of anything you did not listen to enough music this year, plenty of bands even did this better than this band. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/06/oceans-of-slumber-where-gods-fear-to.html


4-Lowen - "Do Not Go To War With The Demons Of Mazandaran"

This album was so bad I could not get through it to review it just felt like a waste of time. It was a flowery mess of symphonic pop rock. The only reason it was disappointing was because it was a shame the album title was so cool, and the music sounded like nothing that should be described like that. 

3-Nightwish- 'Yesterwynde"

Much like the number four I could not get through this album to review it, it's a shame as I liked both "Once" and "Dark Passion Play", there is no backbone driving these songs the attempts at metal sound empty, they would have been better off putting this band to rest. 


2-Unto Others -"Never Neverland" 

I had hoped they would have gone in a more goth direction, but they went in a poppier direction. It sounds like Billy Idol b-sides at times, a great deal of hair metal mixed in but with none of the metal edge.  The pop hooks lured me into giving this album a 9, but if I went back to review this album again I would give it an 8, as the pop hooks did not work to make me want to listen to it again. 


https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/08/unto-others-never-neverland.html



1-Judas Priest - "Invincible Shield" 


Judas Priest is one of my favorite bands from my teen years, age has not been kind to Halford's pipes, though "Nostradomus" was a great album, perhaps I am in the minority in this regard, but it was more inspired than what they have put out since. This album might fool many people just hungry for Priest as it sounds good from a production stand point, though the original members are beginning to dwindle. At the end of the day if we are being honest this album sounds like the record label asked AI to write what it thought a Judas Priest album should sound like and this is what happened. I gave this a 9, when I first reviewed it but the more I listened to it the more I disliked it so I would give it a 7 today.  

https://abysmalhymns.blogspot.com/2024/03/judas-priest-invincible-shield.html


pst658

Dax Riggs : "7 Songs For Spiders"






Here's my first review of a 2025 release.  It's been 13 years since his last release. This time around  Dax is backed by a three-piece band of grooving Cajuns, they slither with a melancholy pulse, that takes things back to his darker roots. The opening track"Deceiver" finds a dream-laden haze hovering over his soulful speculation. It's almost like gospel music for someone whose acid trip has been tempered by opiates. It feels like it picks up closer to what 'We Sing of Only Blood or Love" let off, though more sonically layered. His trademark croon sounds as good as ever. 

The synths going into "sunshine felt the darkness smile" create an almost Beatles-like vibe. Lyrically brilliant, he continues to ponder with his surreal phrasing the duality of Jesus and Lucifer, amid musing issues of mortality. The fuzzed-out bass line occupies the space that guitars normally fill in rock music. This allows the ambiance to breathe. "Even the Stars Fall" is more rock than the previous two songs, as the guitar begins to provide more of a drive, while Riggs throws his croon around.  There is some ebb and flow, where previous releases felt like he was wrestling with depression, this time around you suspect that perhaps marijuana is helping elvate him from the emotional morass, and more hopeful in his esoteric questioning 

'blues for you know who" feels only marginally influenced by the actual blues, though given his cultural background it's enmeshed in his DNA, no matter where he goes sonically, as he continues to give a more soul performance than any of his previous projects. It drones off the bass line and slowly builds rather than winding around a verse-chorus arrangement. "ain't that darkness" is a wandering jam, that is hard to complain about as it flows like syrup. "pagan moon" might have the most blues in its DNA. There is a steamy tension that he makes the most of. He has always been one of the most underrated singers, he knows where to put each note and pours the right amount of emotive despondency behind them. 

The bass lines of this album put more rock into the sound than the guitars, and this is perhaps most displayed in how it drives the last song.It has a surreal grunge feel, with Riggs' emotive croon doing what he does.  Sure, it's only seven songs, but he got them pretty perfect for what they are, and it's a welcome return for him preceding his reunion with Acid Bath. If you were going into this album expecting metal, then you really are not familiar with anything he's done since Agents of Oblivion. I'll give it a 10 and see how it grows on me. 

ost657

Tuesday, December 24, 2024

Hässlig :"Apex Predator"








Ok now we get into the time of year when I review albums that might have slipped by or been promoted in a way that caught my attention, however, they were number one on the lists of my peers so I am seeing if they are worth their praises. In this case, it's Cvlt Nation's number-one-ranked Black Metal album. A band from Spain, which is whatfirst made me skeptical, also, this is a black metal-punk rock hybrid, which could mean they just can't play their instruments. The first track sounds good. Here we get into the crux of what this album is about which I am not surprised, that it's a band that captured a raw grimy sound that is angry enough to work. 

This album turns into the issue of sound vs songs. Anyone can get a found it's about turning the dials of the right equipment. Not everyone can write a song. The problem with this is when you are four songs in and it still sounds like it's the second song, which was not as good as the first song. The vocals and the production are the most black metal thing about these guys if you had a punk yelling it would be punk. There is a little more chaos in the title track, but sounds like a mushy jumble of distortion with incomprehensible singing over it. What's the replay value of that? There is a descending pattern that breaks things up but it's too little too late and just goes back into what they have already done. 

"Abgrund" is back into the cacophony. It's raw but in a way that makes it just noise. You can hear a bass trying to fight its way through this mess. Feedback is the only thing that clues you into the fact that you are not still listening to the previous song. This album gets worse in this regard, sometimes the drums are not blasting at you but there is never anything to hook you in or make this memorable. "Raping the Exoskeleton of Life" is a great song title, but it sounds like everything else on this album. The fact they stretch that out for four minutes is just a waste of time. This would not make my best of black metal list , but it is worthy of my worst albums of 2024 list, as you can hear the first thirty seconds of almost every song and get the gist of what they are doing here, which is making thirty minutes of my life that I am never getting back after listening to this piece of shit. I'll give this album a 3. This is a lower score than Beyonce who claimed the number one spot on my worst of 2024, but she remains the champion of suckage since it took a assembly line of producers and songwriters in the most expensive studios to put out trash while these guys did it with dignity in their basements playing their own instruments.  







pst656

Monday, December 23, 2024

Traveler " Prequel to Madness"








This Canadian band has received great recognition at the end of the year when it comes to a band holding down heavy metal. "Take the Wheel" kicks off the album with an "Aces High" like energy, though the vocals do not have as much grit and guts as Bruce.  Not the most original thing I have heard, but they are good at what they are doing. The Maiden riffs as "Two Minutes to Midnight" are up next, so they might have tried to cover "Powerslave" from front to back. The vocals show a little more guts on this one. I think what is happening here is that an audience is so hungry for new music like this that they do not care how original it is. 

The first song we get that is not trying to rip off Maiden is "The Law", which is as anthemic as any power metal song you might hope for, but mainly empty calories for your ears. The first song that I feel is well-written is 'Rebels of Earth". The riff has a more Dio-like feel to it. "Heavy Hearts" is when things started to fade into background noise and I had to go back and give it another listen to wrap my head around it, this song feels rushed though the chorus works. When their signer tries to belt from his chest voice in a lower register it sounds awkward on "No Fate".

There is a more solid take on traditional metal with "Vagrants of Time".  Though the vocal phrasing could use some work, it's common for these types of singers to try to cram too many words into a verse. Dio seldom did this which is why he is so revered. Despite this being a fact the average listener might not pick up on.  The last song is more of the same, falling along the more typical power metal lines, and too happy for my tastes. I will give this album an 8, they are great at capturing this sound and can pull it off which earns then such a high score since it's not an easy genre to tackle if so more bands would be doing it. 





pst655

Lifeless Dark : "Forces of Nature's Transformation"

 This Boston band takes British crust sounds and fuses them with thrashing aggression. This manages to not sound like early Carcass. They use more punk speed when the song throws itself into the pit. Their vocalist gives more of a punk yell to things. I prefer the more deliberate chug of "Cryptic Remains" over the more rushed punk explosion of the second song. While it retains the raw urgency needed to get the point across this album is well-recorded. Perhaps the drum could come up a little in the mix but aside from that the powerful guitar tone works well. 

"Radition Sickness" has an effective moshing groove, until they pour the speed on, this is the creative battle this band fights with itself. The chorus could stand a little more hook. "Medusa' is not as catchy as the Anthraxz song with the same name. It is more deliberate which works better than most. "Fear No Evil" works as a hyper-aggressive thrashing, her vocals continue to cry out with a uniform abandon. "Chalice of Vision" raced by with angry guitars in such a manner that it blurred into the background so I had to give it a second listen. The same could be said for "Broken Mirrors". At first, the riff has more bit until they give in to their need for speed. There is a cool riff amid the blitzed chaos, but the rule here is "Cool riffs alone does not a good song make" 

The last song opens with a burly bass line. They bust into the kind of raw thrash-tinged punk that has dominated this album and it works well enough. Overall this album could have stood to have had a little more melodic layer to keep the songs from bearing such a uniform feel, but instead, they opt to work off the angry energy alone which is pretty effective in its own right so I will give this album an 8.5




pst654