It's been ten years since their last album was released, and while metal has changed a little since then, it hasn't changed as much as it has over their career, which reaches back to the 80s. They tried to shake the 80s from their sound to survie the 90s and did better than some bands in that regard. Rather than expect them to sound likea band from 2020, what I am listening for here is how this measures up against the likes of "Among the Living," a top-tier album not just for thrash but metal as a whole. Even on "State of Euphoria" and "Persistence of Time," they had a hard time measuring up to that one. They open this album with "The Long Goodbye," which is what the band should be in 2026.
At 65, Belladonna's voice has held up in a way that serves the band, as he retains a commanding tone, but it's unlikely he can still reach his upper register. In 2026, the falsetto yodels would point them in the direction of power metal. "It's For the Kids" feels like filler from the "State of Euphoria" album, almost trying too hard to be anthemic and not as focused as the previous song. They reach a better balance of hardcore punch with melodic 80s thrash sensibility on "Everybody's Got a Plan.". Scott Ian has called "Edge of Perfection" the best Anthrax song in the history of the band. It sounds like they are trying their hand at being Deafheaven until they lock into a groove for Joey to sing on. I will go ahead and say this song is nowhere near what they did on "I am the Law" or even "Keep it in the Family". Not sure why they need to use a blast beat to make themselves feel relevant. I like the effects they use on his voice midway into the song before the guitar solo.
I will tell you that "Infectious" is a better song than "Edge of Perfection". It has more groove, and the vocals fit with more confidence. Sure, there is a little rock swagger to it, but a good song is a good song. Thanks to the ex-Shadows Fall guitarist Jonathan Donau, their guitar solos are less chaotic, and those sections flow more smoothly. "NYC 93" finds the band trying to convince themselves they are still a crossover band. They sound more like themselves on the title track. This does not mean it's a nostalgia fest but a more effective modern translation.
'T.O.M.B" finds a meaner guitar tone crunching in, but the groove keeps things in the wheelhouse of what you want from these guys.I guess playing in Pantera has rubbed off on Charlie when it comes to this one. "Watch it Go" works well and shows they can add a more modern approach to heaviness without compromising who they are. "My Victory" also finds the balance of flirting with hardcore aggression while still being who they are. I will give this album a 9.5 and see how it sits with me , there are songs that I am unsure of biut they are balanced out by strong moemtns that stand against their classic work, which is all I am asking for.
