darker shades of metal, hymns of goth and post-punk ...all for the worship of darkness
Friday, February 6, 2026
Puscifer : "Normal Isn't"
Monday, September 30, 2024
Gothtober - Night Club : "Masochist"
I reviewed their 2018 album "Scary World' this time things are even more polished. Maynard lends his voice to the opening track. This gives things more of a Puscifer feel despite his voice sharing the spotlight in the mix with Emily's.. "Barbwire Kiss". A disco bass line drives "Another Side of You". Not the first time disco has been fused with dark music., though here it is in a slicker more pop-minded manner than what My Life With the Thrill Kill Kult has done. Emily's vocal lines are also hookier this time around which plays to their favor.
"Crime Scene' has a decent groove, but does not grab me as strongly as the first three songs. It carries a more 80s feel to it especially when it comes to the big chorus. Though the production is very 2024. "Let's Play Revenge' feels like it should be the theme song of a teen horror movie. Despite the coy lyrics it's not that dark of a song and finds them back in a more disco mode. I can hear "The Lunatics Have Taken Over the Asylum" making into the rotation of a goth nite. There is almost a Britney Spears-like thump to "Pretty Girls Do Ugly Things".
'Fatal Crush' is another darker pop slapper. It is not as sultry as the previous song but works pretty well. Emily is not working with the best pipes in the business but she makes wise choices of where to put her voice. It's back to disco for "Everybody Knows". I will give this album a 9, it moves in a more disco direction but the slicker pop angle works well for it.
pst471
Sunday, May 28, 2023
Live Review : "Welcome to Rockville 2023"
I will start off by saying , the whole Maynard doing drag pretty much a non issue, and even after going to the press to say he was not doing it as a protest ,but just something he sometimes does, yet certain publications want to run with it for the clicks. This is sensationalizing something that was a non-factor, unless you were in the front row, I was standing by the soundboard and Maynard just looked like a shadow against the video screen for the first hour of the set , which is all I could stand . It was the most boring performance of the day. It reminded me of why I don't like the new album as they were half way into "Pneuma" when I realized they were not playing a reworked version of "Schism" . So this is the bad news first, that once the wonderment of the Pink Floyd visuals wore off and the band blew their load with "Forty Six & 2" they would prove to be the most tedious disappointment of the day, and I am saying that after being logistically forced to watch some bands that I am not into.
Now with that out of the way, let's look at the high lights. The first band we caught was Holy Wars. Having only heard a few of their songs, I thought I would take the chance and brave the heat for them. This is a much larger stage than the Los Angeles pop act normally command, but front woman Kat Leon proved to be a highly entertaining performer. She shifted through rapping, singing and screaming with ease, there was more menace to be found than the more sterilized pop nature to their studio work thus far. They are band that is better live, as it forces them to embrace a more organic element, and brings the guitars to the forefront. Leon's live persona has a dominant sexual energy that gives the songs a heavier feel.
After "Holy Wars" we has some time to kill so caught Capital Theater, as the next band we wanted to see was Deafheaven, but that was three hours away. Capital Theater are middle of the rock, that draws from both early 2000s emo and Jeff Buckley in equal measure, while having prog rock ambitions that are never fully realized. Then we wandered over to another stage for Filter. The years have not been kind to Richard Patrick. It was like someone's dad came in from a game of golf to fill in on Filter cover tunes. Patrick is the sole member of this band with a trio of hired guns backing him. What he had going for him were strong songs left over from back in the day, that held up no matter which way they beat them.
Then we caught Attila. There is metal core, then there is whatever you want to call the Juggalo flavored rock this Atlanta band plays. It sounds like the more trailer infested suburbs further out of the city limits, rather than the kind of bands the city normally spawns. People were having fun, though it was interesting to see this subset of the attendees who not only also attend the Gathering but looked to have a taste for harder drugs than weed. It was weird for Deafheaven to follow this sort of thing. Having seen Deafheaven four times previous, this was not their normally performance as they were out of their element, and not playing to their base. George Clarke, was forced to be more engaging and extroverted. Either way they came out and kicked ass hard with an intense set , that showed the crowd that metal was more than their Sirrus XM mainstream fodder. They did this with a great balance of their blasting beaten blitz and the dreamy post-rock at the other end of their polarity.
At some point we caught a little of Senses Fail, which sounding like motivational emo for fraternity brothers. Then Incubus who we were forced to listen to while waiting for Deftones. Incubus are professional and pulls their shit off, but they have a long history now of writing bland radio muzak. Boyd looked like he is slowly becoming Steven Tyler, and their new bassist looked like she was from Haim at first. Then Deftones took the stage, the last time I saw them live was likely 20 years ago. Things have changed. They do have a bigger production, with movies playing in the background, but with their 'bi" lighting comes a mellower vibe where they are more about simmering in mood with just enough rock to remind you who they are. Their studio material has been moving in this direction for sometime.
I have searched for this online and with all the press backing tracks are getting, perhaps it is being surprised, but I know for a fact, there was a dude with long hair who was coming out to a microphone stand that was behind the bass player and handling a good deal of the harsher screams. Chino did a few if it was a single scream he sustained , but none of the more rapid punchy screamed sections which were handled as a call and response by this long haired stranger. I am of the mind a single singer should do both , but the overall performance was enjoyable, there was some energy to hit so not a case of them totally showing up and punching the time clock to get paid, but more in that direction than when I saw them earlier in their career.
When Tool... I have already talked about their performance, which if you take into consideration the higher energy artists that played for them, aside from the stage spectacle provided by the lights and video projections, the ponderous songs seemed heavier on the pretense, no matter what era they came from. Granted I was inspired to leave before the final two songs, but it is unlikely they would have changed my mind as Maynard's voice was not getting any better as the night went one. It was so drenched in effects it was hard to find the tone of his actual voice. Danny Carey was on point, as was the rest of the band, no one is going to deny they are a caliber of musician that is head above the rest. That does not mean they are also going to be a fully engaged entertainer, as they could have been balancing their checks books in the heads as they played.
Overall it was a fun day. To get me back out into a crowd of 170000 people again they are going to need to bring the heat with a performer I really care about like that the only ones that come to my mind who could get me back out would be Iron Maiden, King Diamond, Metallica or Ozzy, any body else I am into at that level, would not likely be booked though Killing Joke is a maybe, but not likely. It was not as hot as I feared though standing up all day was rough, the prices of sodas not outrageous for concert pricing, and the overall layout and guest experience was well done, so maybe see ya there again?
Wednesday, February 1, 2023
The Top 200 Greatest Rock Singers - 30 to 21
Now we are in the top 30 and harder choices are having to be made. I am having to be more honest with myself; in what we are doing here which is focusing not only on technical vocal ability, in terms of range and power, as well as their dynamics, phrasing and the overall character of their voice. Can they emote from different places? How well does their voice hold up live? . How they control a crowd or their entertainment value as performers is also not a factor; there are some great front men who are also sub-par singers. There are also not going to be any Bob Dylan like singers, who are better songwriters than vocalists.
Pop singers, are far and few between, with; a few country or jazz singers who crossover just enough to qualify for this list, while having a significant influence on rock music. Don't expect rappers on this list or metal vocalists who just scream or growl, but never actually sing. I am keen on singers who are derivative of other singers. The bulk of these do their own thing, the few paying tribute to other artists made enough of an impact with their music. Having a unique vocal quality is going to be one of the most important factors often trumping technical ability. If they sound too much like Steve Perry from Journey after listening to their vocal coach rather than developing their own style, it is also not going to fly. Some of these might have been ignored by mainstream music media, but by the time we get to the top 10, I am sure it will all make sense, so here are the Top 200 greatest rock singers.
30-Chino Moreno
From hushed cooing to full on hard core like screaming, his voice has grown over the years which kept his band from being lost in the mire of nu metal an evolving into their own thing.
29-Maynard James Keenan
The Tool singer who has branched out into projects like A Perfect Circle and Puscifer, has come a long way since he was raging with more of a metal band on the Opiate ep, though even then we heard his potential. He might not try as hard these days, but laid the ground work well.
28- Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan
Not only the greatest of his kind but he brought his traditions into a modern setting by working with western producers. His voice is a spiritual experience.
27-Skin
The front woman for Skunk Anansie knows no bounds when it comes to what she does with her voice. It is a shame they never broke bigger in the States as their are singers who have tired to do what she does and got more credit for not even covering half the ground she does vocally.
26 Cedric Bixler
How often would a band like Mars Volta find themselves putting out songs that are even better than what they were doing 20 years ago. Cedric is the reason for this. Not as aggressive as he was during At the Drive In, he has taken his androgynous voice to new highs.
25--George Michael
After he shattered the world with the Faith album , he followed it up with an album that solidified him as the best make POP singer of his era. He should have been the one to replace Freddie.
24- Chris Isaak
His smooth style of melancholy rock a billy crooning with a mellow western feel , would not hit like it does without his mastery of his falsetto yodels. His low end notes are gutsy and he has tons of power, making him even better live than in the studio.
23-Chris Cornell
The Soundgarden singer continued to make an impression on people with his solo career before he died. He had a Robert Plant like wail to his voice that made him stand out among his peers who were just baritones.
22-King Diamond
You might be surprised the King is not in the top 10 , he would if this was just metal singers. He does have the best metal yodel, but metal yodels alone does not the best make, that is even including his death metal demon snarls and doomsayer moans .King Diamond is great at the songs he wrote , but can you imagine him covering some one else in his style?
21-Peter Steele
How did Peter Steele beat out King Diamond. It was a tough, but, given his band's penchant for covering a song and making it better and his resonate baritone that finds him being able to gracefully navigate a wider range of melodic territory , unless we were ranking by voices most likely to summon Satan then King wins hands down.Wednesday, November 4, 2020
Puscifer : "Existential Reckoning"
The first song falls more in line with the last A Perfect Circle album, softer and more focused on atmosphere, like a more indie lo fi version of Depeche Mode. It is well produced and the vocals sit just right in the mix . They nailed the sound they are going for and Maynard makes an effort that the song writing. Very synth oriented. Not that this project has not always been in that vein, it is not as focused on the groove as "the Conditions of My Parole" . "Apocalyptical" finds the vocals dancing around 80s like synth wave. There is more movement to this song so I prefer it to the opener. There is also a more defined guitar riff to this one. Not rock music, but looking in that direction. Things get progressively more interesting with each song.
A more solid sense of groove develops on "the Underwhelming" . "Grey Area" finds the more synth wave sounds returning , but with more motion in the ocean, and guitar accents to create an almost heavy feel. Then "Theorem" sounds like it was made with children's toys. There are interesting sounds , but not sure it's the best song. "Upgrade" sounds like if androids wrote a song for Depeche Mode. Maynard's voice sounds better on "Bullet Train to Iowa". If he puts effort into it his voice alone can save most songs, the problem is he sometimes wants to wander around the songs. "Personal Prometheus" grew on me, the composition is interesting and subtle. Lyrically it is also one of the strongest songs.
The way the vocals create a narcotic throb with "A Singularity " works well even with the 80s sounds around it. This could very well have been a Phil Collins song with a different approach to the vocals . The pace picks up a little for "Postulous" , that is more than enough groove for me. He finally puts some balls to his voice on "Fake Affront" /You can tell there is some Kate Bush influence on how the vocals fall when the song builds. I like hearing his lower register on the vocal going into the last song. I will give this album a 9.5 as it is one of the best releases from this project, and more interesting than the last Tool album.
Sunday, August 25, 2019
Tool : " Fear Inoculum"
13 years has passed since "10,000 Days" was released. That in itself being an album that was not the band's best as they began recycling riffs from their previous album. After this 13 year wait they have a released an album 7 songs in which all but one are over 10 minutes. The problem wit the first single and title track, was it was long and ponderous lacking most of the coiled punch that makes the band work. Granted it's been since "Laterlus" they have been on this winding prog road. Even that album knows when it's time to rock and cares about the songs. One second listens to the title track it grows on me by maybe four degrees higher. It still like they are warming up ideas recycled from other songs. It's also not that heavy. "Pneuma" opens with a strum and pattering of exotics drums.Much like "Schism" it works off a building and odd time signature to bring the tension. It's almost a rip off of "Schism".. I do like the vocals to this song better than the first. The vocals are the only thing that make it work and not a total carbon copy of "Schism" as the instrumentation is going for that even in how it's arranged.
"Descending" continues the trend of "Laterlus" resurrection this time pulling from songs like "the Patient" and "Parabola". If you do not hear it , it is because you do not want to. This puts all the weight Maynard to vary the vocals and retain the song's identity, which he does better in some places than others. They would not be the first band to plagiarize themselves , but just how progressive is it?The guitar solos on this is Adam Jones's moment to shine, though the melody it reverts to is too familiar. In the atmospheric break down there are some new sounds that get drowned by rehash, though it's well p[produced and executed rehash. "Culling Voices" starts off giving me hope that perhaps I will get just one that does not sound like something else I have already heard from them. Midway into the song it begins taking on a sense of familiarity when the guitar kicks in for the predictable build up section. 'Still nothing all that heavy or aggressive. Which is what I feared as what is heavy in 2019 has progressed where these guys are still where they were in 2006 and truth be told when that album came out it did not seem as heavy as they once came across.
"Chocolate Chip Trip" is it is Danny Carey doing a drum solo to electronic noises. Drummers will be impressed I am sure. If the most original thing is their take on "Moby Dick" well that is no good. They end the album with the 15 minute "Tempest". The droning clean guitar that opens the song drones in a way that displays where some of the fat could have been cut from the start. Minute and a half into it we get the first riff where they are actually rocking out. Maynard's vocals are more aggressive. The grove is not original but thanks to the vocals it works. There is a "Dazed & Confused" middle section where Jones should pull out the bow that they jam on for sometime. This song does redeem some of the more indulgent moments even though it's 15 minutes and nothing 100 percent new from them it is well done. All the this album is well executed so that is why I am rounding it down to a 9 and I am tempted to take it another notch down to an 8.5 for making us wait this long for warmed up left overs.But maybe it will grow on me. It's a step down from "10000 Days which had many more moments of originality I think this album will work well live because rather than decided which of their classics to play they have written a medley that pulls from all of them. Nothing new to hear here.
Friday, March 15, 2019
80s vs 90s
Inspired by a Facebook debate. I decided to weigh them in pound for pound to see who really had the better music of the two . The first dozen are pitting artists against their own work. Then the next dozen are artist vs artist.
1988 Jane's Addiction - "Nothing's Shocking" Vs 1990 "Ritual de lo Habitual"
So we are not looking for what was a better hit, as most radio songs are shit since they are packaged for masses which is the lowest common denominator. We are looking for which album is better. Hand's down "Nothings Shocking" wins this one. Sure there is "Three Days" for it to contend with, but "Ted, Just Admit it" and "Mountain Song" slam this one home.
80s -1
90s- 0
1989 Nirvana- "Bleach" vs 1991 "Nevermind"
Sure "Nevermind" took grunge to the masses, meaning the songs were user friendly enough for widespread radio consumption. "Bleach" has more emotion behind it and songs like "Love Buzz" , "Floyd the Barber" and "About a Girl" beat out "Smells Like Teen Spirit". They are more brooding and have more balls.
80s- 2
90s-0
1989 Soundgarden -"Louder Than Love" vs 1991 "Badmotorfinger"
We have already covered the fact we do not care about hits, so that takes "Rusty Cage" out of the equation, but even then there are 5 good songs on it. "Louder Than Love" is darker and has a more sensual throb to it . "Jesus Christ Pose" you say? "Gun" is a better song.
80s- 3
90s-0
1989 Faith No More- "the Real Thing" vs 1992 "Angel Dust"
This was tough as there are some great songs on "the Real Thing". "Angel Dust" found the band giving mainstream a middle finger and went harder and darker , so " Angel Dust" wins out.
80s- 3
90s- 1
1989 Nine Inch Nails - "Pretty Hate Machine" vs 1994 "the Downward Spiral"
"Pretty Hate Machine" is a great album though in more of a Depeche Mode direction. "Downward Spiral" has a more emotional heaviness to it , along with vastly better production quality and guitar sound so it wins
80s3
90s- 2
1986 Metallica - "Master of Puppets" vs 1991 "the Black Album"
Are you fucking kidding me ? This is not even close. There is no need to even explain this. If you don't get it , then you don't know shit about metal.
80s-4
90s- 2
1987 Guns N Roses - Appetite For Destruction vs 1991 "Use Your Illusion pt 1 & 2"
Another one that needs little explanation. Add all the good songs on their 1991 double album and they won't be able to touch "Appetite"
80s-5
90s-2
1987 R.E.M "Document" vs 1992 "Automatic For The People"
This is a tough one as the 1992 album is full of raw emotion and is one of Stipe's best performances. "Document" wins this one as it finds the band working at the peak of their power being an actual rock band rather than dripping with ballads .
80s- 6
90s-2
1987 U2 "the Joshua Tree" vs 1991 "Achtung Baby"
The 87 has a ton of hits on the front end , but the b-side tanks . Their 1991 album thus proves superior.
80s -6
90s-3
1985 the Smiths "Meat is Murder" vs 1991 Morrissey "Kill Uncle"
I love Moz's solo work, but the Smiths made some of the best albums ever
80s-7
90s-3
1986 Slayer "Reign in Blood" vs 1990 "Seasons in the Abyss"
Closer to call than "Master of Puppets " and " the Black Album". "Reign In Blood" is more of what Slayer is .
80s-8
90s-3
1980 Black Sabbath "Heaven & Hell" vs 1991 Ozzy Osbourne - "No More Tears"
While most 70s Ozzy Sabbath albums would win this one, Dio Sabbath dominates 90s solo Ozzy, even 80s Ozzy consistently beats out "No More Tears".
80s-9
90s-3
ok now artist vs artist - we are looking at the artists of note for their respected decades and pitting them against artists from a similar genre.
Iron Maiden vs Tool
The battle of prog metal. Tool was once one of my favorite bands since their inception in 1990, but Iron Maiden who if we are just counting the Bruce years have stood the test of time since 1982. I sometimes get the urge to revisit Tool , they waned 4 albums in where Maiden was kicking ass well past that .
80s 10
90s 3
The Cure vs Smashing Pumpkins
Moody rock for pasty white kids. Smashing Pumpkins really only had 2 solid albums under their belt, neither of which can hold a candle to "Pornography" much less "Disintegration"
80s 11
90s 3
Kate Bush vs Tori Amos
Kate might have had 2 albums out by the time the 80s rolled around, but the bulk of her work is from the 80s. Tori Amos owes her entire sound to Kate Bush...end of story.
80s 12
90s 3
Tears For Fears vs Radiohead
After "Ok Computer" Radiohead gave the record label the middle finger and got darker and more experimental. However if we look at who has the better songs, Tears For Fears beats out the bulk of Thom Yorke's introspective whining.
80s 13
90s 3
Siouxsie and the Banshees vs Bjork
This one is a close call so it boils down to the prolific body consistent work and Bjork only had 3 albums that would be overwhelmed by the 7 Siouxsie put out.
80s 14
90s-3
The Cult vs Pearl Jam
Battling for the throne left vacant by Jim Morrison . It comes down to "Electric" and "Sonic Temple" against "Ten " and "Vs" so Eddie Veddar and friends are going to walk away the winners here.
80s 14
90s-4
Motley Crue vs Stone Temple Pilots
Drugged out arena rockers clash . This boils down to the fact the first 2 Crue albums crush anything STP put out .
80s 15
90s 4
Prince vs Lenny Kravitz
Lets not even get into who is the better singer and guitarist, that's a no brainer. Has Kravitz ever dreamed of touching "Purple Rain"...hell no.
80s 16
90s 4
Cocteau Twins vs Cranberries
"Every Body is Doing it So Why Don't We" is a great album and got more airplay, but it's not "Blue Bell Knoll"
80s 17
90s 4
Def Leppard vs Foo-fighters
Ok both are cheesy radio rock. Def Leppard's songs stick with me better.
80s 18
90s 4
Celtic Frost vs Korn
Korn did inspire a generation of glue sniffers to tune down to b. Celtic Frost's music was ahead of it's time and continues to influence black metal . Less daddy issues and more thoughtful
80s 19
90s 4
the Misfits vs Green Day
Is this even up for debate ?
80s 20
90s 4
final score it's a massacre 20 to 4
Monday, May 7, 2018
The Top 50 Metal Guitarists - 20 to 11
The death of a guitarist I played with turned my thoughts to what makes a good guitarist great. Metal finds the stakes for guitarists high. Shredding can come before playing a fucking song. While all of these guitarists can play a solo, I was also looking for tone, impact on the genre as a whole and how their personalities came through in their playing. So this list of the top 50 Metal Guitarists. If you don't find your favorite guitar player here then know they were just wankers.
20- Kerry King
Sure his solos are formulaic,and has a punk sloppiness to it at times but his playing has a fire to it that helps define the sound of his band. Marrying metal and punk at the cross roads that became thrash. He uses an evil chaos in his playing that made his band darker than the other thrash bands at the time.
19-Ihsahn
His playing goes beyond black metal. Romantic touches of neo-classical gives a more gothic touch to the architecture of his songs.He has branched out to 8 strings for his solo work. More of a shredder than you might expect he will go down as underrated except on this list where he is earning his rightful place.
18-Adam Jones
He doesn't solo in the traditional sense. He does add sonic dynamics where solos would go and is almost jazz like in the way he gives the drums and bass room to breathe. He knows how to keep the tension and get a big arena rock sound when needed. He influenced an entire generation of progressive metal players who live for the groove no matter how complex or simple.
17-Kirk Hammett
He has some memorable solos. His band is known for their big riffs, but he works around the chugs and gallops owing more of a rock sensibility to his playing that heavy metal thunder. I don't think his band could work without him even though he stepped in to replace Dave Mustaine many moons ago.
16-Kim Thayll
How could he beat out Hammet you ask? His playing is more creative and darker. He uses up more sonic space to create a sense of unease on his band's earlier work, but is able to solo with the best of them when it is called for. He weaves in noise and chaos while still managing to create grunge anthems that dominated the air waves.
15-Zakk Wylde
He had some big shoes to fill. Rather than living in the shadow of the great players who stood beside he boss before he, Wylde carved out his own sound and brought something new to the table. He could pulls off the Randy Rhodes stuff with his own flair which was impressive live.
14 Arve Isdal
Until you see this guy rock it live you have no idea. He is the prime reason his band almost blew Dimmu Borgir off the stage. They might play viking prog, but his playing keeps the band rooted in the rock side of classic metal.
13- Don Anderson
He can pulls a sweep arpeggio out of thin air, despite the fact he is mainly adding melody to the more post-rock side of his former band Agalloch. I haven't sought out his current project as Agalloch is a moment in time I do not want to put down.
12- Ace Frehely
You wanted the best you got the best. He plays guitar for the hottest band in the land. Technically he is outclassed by many players ranked lower than him, but chances are they would not have picked up a guitar in the first place if it was not for him.His solo work is also pretty decent for all you rock soldiers who want the Ace back like he told you so.
11- Trey Azagthoth
He took what Kerry King did and sacrificed it to the Ancient Ones. It returned back to this plan as death metal and crushed many souls. The unique twisted on his personification of chaos, sets him aside as his own island in a genre guilty of rehashing the same old grind. He is the Eddie Van Halen of death metal.
Friday, May 4, 2018
Looking Back in Anger at Tool's "Aenima"
Continuing to listen back to Tool's catalog and see how it holds up in this case 25 years later.The band's second full length finds them being elevated into legendary status. In the days before the internet the mystery of what they were doing gave them more mystique. They open the song with an arena rock sized groove and explosive chorus. Maynard's vocals are much more nuanced and the production gives a bigger sound all the way around that bands trying not to be nu-metal would begin to copy. The groove to " Eulogy" is more subtle and less of a dramatic departure from where they were on "Undertow". The chords are bigger and more powerful when they do build dynamically. The most dramatic shift in their sound was the more introspective space given to "H" that gives Maynard's vocals more room to breath, thus proving that he can really sing his ass off in a very honest emotional way.
The most impressive introduction of Justin Chancellors playing is on "Forty Six & 2". The bass slithers in a very hypnotic fashion. Working off a expand and retract loud to soft dynamic that now is more common place, here this held a great deal of weight and power and is Danny Carey's first real shining moment on this album where he really establishes himself as a monster, The album's heaviest and most aggressive moment comes on the industrial strength pound of "Hooker With a Penis" where Maynard rages against the machine on selling out. The album balance out the dynamic contrast with "Jimmy" which broods on a more esoteric groove, with the vocal providing both aggression and atmosphere. "Push It" is not only Maynard's best vocal performance , but the lyrical depth is moving. The dynamics are very graceful, proving their shade of heavy can be beautiful. The title track is powerful, but doesn't seem as heavy as it did when this album came out. Lyrically it remains relevant.
" Third Eye" sampled Bill Hicks and brought this genius who masqueraded as a comedian to another generation who might have missed out on his truth if not for this introduction. This song is sonically intense and writhes around in a hypnotically exotic manner. Another song that seemed really heavy in it's day , but paired against the likes of Meshuggah or Deathspell Omega not so much. The vocals in the more atmospheric break are great. I like the mood swings this song displays. This is one of the rare albums that has to go all the way up to an 11 when I score it. Perhaps twenty other albums I can think of might come to mind deserving of such a score, maybe more as Chelsea Wolfe might not be the first who comes to mind though I know that she earned one at one point. Still this is to say it falls under an elite class of albums that go beyond what we thought perfect could be. But how will the albums after this one hold up ?
Monday, April 30, 2018
Looking Back In Anger at Tool's "Undertow"
Continuing to listen back to Tool's catalog and see how it holds up in this case 25 years later. The timing of the band's first full length couldn't have been more perfect. Grunge had set the stage for something this dark and dense. Aside from Maynard's vocals the tight maze like winding of the riffs almost sound like a different band than the one that played on the e.p. Maynard's vocals go right along with the tension they are weaving behind him. Sonically this is like collision of early Swans with King Crimson. More groove than math the chanted vocal swells pummel you with tribal intensity. The bass sounds incredible. Paul D' Amour has a more growling tone than the more progged out groove that the band would eventually churn out. "Intolerance" is a perfect song and the same could be said for the more introspective victim anthem "Prison Sex". Here the groove slithers more fluidly and lends itself to a more crooned melody from Keenan. "Release in sodomy/ for one sweet moment/ I am home" are not lyrics you could find on another metal album up to this point, even Judas Priest' homo eroticism was veiled in thicker metaphor.
The abstract lyrics painted a picture of the dark struggles one suspected was in Maynard's head. These were shrouded in the kind of mystery that would continue to make the band an enigma. The introspective musings of "Sober" have a good dose of self loathing to go with the infectious pulse of the bass driving the song. Maynard's vocal performance here might be the album's most passionate. One of the rare occasions where the album's radio single was not pandering to the lowest common denominator. The self loathing continues on the tighter grooves of "Bottom" until Henry Rollins comes in for the self help seminar crammed into a few bars. Their is more complicated resentments being processed on "Crawl Away" which in the wake of nu-metal that followed might seem like more angst ridden metal fodder, but felt fresh when this was released and might not strike me as the album's most inspired lyrics listening back to this, but the riffs compensate for this. The bass playing continues to be incredible, and while Danny Carey has gone onto be known as one of the genre's best drummers, some of that is due to the fact he has had some hellacious bass players to keep up with. His double bass on this songs is pretty tasteful , though aside from the first ep, some of his most straight up metal playing .
The groove and mood to this song still reminds me a little of "Louder Than Love" era Sound Garden. The effects are really well applied to the vocals on this song and help to create the distinct sound we now think of as Maynard. Adam Jones also needs to get a little credit for easing into some more atmospheric moments to give a dynamic shift. The lyrics to the title track begin to paint a murky veil of metaphor and glances at the fact Maynard can really sing with varied dynamics. The drums also get more bombastic in their dynamics as well. This song also has a few moments that certainly seemed really heavy for when this came out, while this might now measure up against Meshuggah, I think the vocal melodies are creative enough to compensate for this. The more homo-erotic hints begins to re-surface in the lyrics to "4 Degrees" . The song has a more sensuous throb to it. "Flood" has a more sludge like atmosphere to the ominous pound it lurches out of .It's impressive how they come out of this four and a half minute drone with the groove of this one, it's a outstanding display of dynamics and Maynard delivers his best vocal performance of the album. They end the album with a wild turn into the more experimental "Disgustipated" which finds the bulk of the song working of the chant of "this is necessary / life feeds on life" . Listening back you can hear the Godflesh / Swans influence on this part.
Overall this finds the band fully realizing their vision, so their only competition is going to become themselves as their influences become more obscured by their progressive leaning. I think this album finds them at their darkest and most tense, two of the things I look for in music, done very well, so this obviously gets a 10.
Sunday, April 29, 2018
Looking Back in Anger at Tool's "Opiate"
There is a stiffer militant anger to "Part of Me". The tightly chugged riff is a prophetic glance at what was to come on "Undertow". Danny Carey's drumming was not as nuanced as it would become on "Undertow". The taunt guitars are actually the song's strong suit, as Maynard's vocals hand really close to the riff. He does display a strong sense of dynamics, and though it's not his best performance on this album , it is more nuanced than the first two songs. Then comes the two live songs. "Cold & Ugly" reminds me of what my high-school girl friend said to me when she brought this album home from the radio station she worked at. "You'll like these guys they are like a more metal version of Soundgarden. I can hear the grunged out sinew pulsing on this song. Of the two songs "Jerk Off" is more like the sound they would further cultivate. Maynard's vocals are more melodic. Danny Carey also begins to really step up his playing on this as well. Not sure how a lyric like "maybe I should play god/ and shoot you myself" would sit with the p/c police.
Of all the songs the title track holds up the best against the band's current body of work. The vocals are the most melodically sung, and lyrically the stab at religion is well done. The production is a little dated in a few places earlier on in the album so I will give this one a 9.5 , it's more straight forward on a metallic manner which sometimes gives it more of a stiffness than the serpentine groove to come on future albums.
Saturday, March 24, 2018
A Perfect Circle : "Eat the Elephant"
It opens with a piano ballad. Production wise it feels different like everything is more compressed despite not using more rock styled instrumentation here. Maynard's vocals is what you would expect from him, though there are a few phrases where the using a more delicate almost androgynous head register. The guitar shows up for "Disillusioned". Lyrically its more of a social commentary, which splits the difference between Tool and what we have heard from this project in the past. The overall sound is more middle of the road like they are going for what was once called "adult contemporary"...think solo Phil Collins with none of the soul . Marginally more moody, Keenan's vocals are higher on "Contrarian". It has more in common with the Pet Shop Boys than Tool. There are some interesting guitar textures which is more than can be said of the first two songs.
They finally find the edge that has been lost for the first three songs on "the Doomed". The guitars get much more metallic. In fact its a more of a clear cut metal riff than we have heard from them before. It trades off with a tinkling synth riff. There is even tension in the guitar when the distortion pedal is not being so trod upon. "So Long and Thanks for All the Fish" is not the song from "Hitch Hikers Guide". It feels like post-90s David Bowie musically, with harmonized vocals. In fact they name drop both Major Tom and Willy Wonka in this state of the union. "Talktalk" is more of political statement about the "alt-rock" who they ask if they are going to talk like Jesus, to try walking like Jesus. The bloated glut of piano that I would be fine with on a Depeche Mode album continues on " By and Down By the River". Maynard's vocals take on more familiar melodies that will make long time fans a little more comfortable. Though if you have stood by this band over the years I don't think there is enough of a difference in the more middle of the road direction to shake you from their tree.
"Delicious" is more of a traditional rock format. It's also more traditional rock song writing which is odd for this band as it would sound more at home on an Hoobastank album. As if there was not enough ponderous piano on this album they have to include an interlude of more. I think my favorite song on here might be the weird electro groove of "Hourglass" that sounds more like a Puscifer song. "Feathers" is the kind of atmospheric rock power ballad that these guys tend to dish out owing equal parts to the Cure and David Bowie. The guitar tone is really dialed in here and maybe I just pushed my ear buds in further , but the bass on the past few songs in more present in the mix. "Get the Lead" out confirms the piano is here to stay. So lump them in with Tori Amos. There is a weird hip hop element that becomes an undercurrent to the song , but in more of a Massive Attack manner. The song cruises on it's atmosphere rather than building into anything substantial. I'll give this album an 8.5, which is better than most bands on the radio, but their first album and "13th Step" would both be 10s if you want some perspective on how it measures up.
Friday, January 12, 2018
Legend of the Seagullmen : "s/t"
A nautical concept album, well not a totally new concept for a member of Mastodon. A super group of sorts as it includes Brent Hinds, Danny Carey and the bassist from Dethklok / Zappa Plays Zappa, as well as some guys who don't pay the rent playing music. I'm not totally sold on the guitar tones on this album, but it might be my earbuds so I am willing to cut it some slack. Layers of overdubbed vocals in chanted choruses. Not Danny Carey's most adventurous playing it's pretty straight forward rock. The bass playing is what steals the spot light most of the time. The vocals tend to be in husky baritone and are exclaimed as much as they are sung. The album's first moment that grabs me is "Shipswreck" which chugs in with the command of classic metal.
I understand that this in someways is to be taken as seriously as Tenacious D, who I am hit or miss with. The power ballad "the Curse of the Red Tide" is a little silly for me. I might have liked it as a teenager, as I can hear this as the kind of power ballad Alice Cooper might have done in a bizarre drunken fit. These songs are not long drawn out epics and most fall somewhere between 70's rock and 80s metal. The title track is pretty much straight up rock.Perhaps too straight up for my personal taste buds, but if you prefer classic rock over metal then this is for you. I prefer the darker, moodier groove to "Orca". This is like when 80s metal sometimes got weird when it collided with prog rock. This might be the album's best song.
The spaghetti western that was the inspiration for this project can be heard on "Ballad of a Deep Sea Diver" which reminds me more of Nick Cave , which was the direction I expected this to originally go in. The guitar playing is pretty stellar on this song and makes up for moments when it was dialed in rock n roll. Overall this album is fun. If you smoke pot I am sure it would sound better, but since I don't I am going to give it an 8.5. Not sure if this is proggy enough for Tool fans, though Mastodon fans will find this easier to swallow.
Friday, October 23, 2015
Puscifer : " Money Shot"

Tool used to be one of my favorite bands. A Perfect Circle was up there as well. Puscifer seemed like Maynard's stab at doing his own Massive Attack , but heavy on the jokes. The first album he mainly used his lower range and further separated himself from being the voice of Tool. First off the album sounds great but sounds best through head phones. More focused on songs and less focused on jokes , with more of an emphasis placed on songs. Closely harmonized with female voices it sounds like this could have been written for a Perfect Circle album that never happened. Former Ministry bassist Paul Barker lays down a groove to "Agostina" is slinky and dark setting the perfect ground work for Keenan to croon over. I don't think Keenan's pipes are going to be in question, he brings the vocals up into a mellower mid-range tenor. "Grand Canyon" is pretty transcendent , but it not as dark as the previous songs so it takes a little to get use to it.
"Simultaneous" opens with a sampled narrative. Its a less organic composition relying on the synths. Its until four minutes in that vocals comes before the over driven bass line and it turns into a real song. Title track whose video is featured below has a more 90s rock like beat to it. It's not metal or anything like Tool, in fact it's closer to something Tomahawk might do. There is some electronic weirdness that collides with it before going into the second verse. There is more atmosphere to "the Arsonist" that comes close to being a ballad. Lyrically this might be one of the better songs, the line "Your social skills resemble arson". It does build at the chorus and the synths get hard with the bass in manner that Perfect Circle might have been more eager to stomp on the distortion for. The despite the driving drums there is a kraut rock feel to the intro of "the Remedy" before dropping down to an ode to unruly house guests. Things get a shade darker with "Smoke and Mirrors". But this is not the albums most interesting song. In a similar dynamic range somewhere between the Cure and darker electronic the vocal work on "the Life of Brian" works much better.
Dynamically "Autumn" takes a few cues from the "13th Step" album. Things have found a better balance here. We will see how this one stands the test of time, Puscifer has generally not last long in my iPod as much like his other projects is in a middle ground that I don't normally dwell on. It's either heavy or ethereal and surreal. I think since this is not a rock album that makes "Money Shot" relevant in a way I am afraid the next Tool album won't be if it ever sees the light of day. I'll round it up to a 9.
Saturday, August 29, 2015
The Top 100 albums of the 90s :10 to 1
So here we are at the end, ultimately these are the ten albums I get the most playtime out of with the top 6 still in my iPod and the others shuffling in and out of it, which considering how much new music I ingest on a daily basis says something about their staying power.
10- Faith No More - "Angel Dust"
When I saw these guys live last month this fact became more than evident. They hit their peak with this one as the bar was raised way to high.
9-Janes Addiction- " Ritual De Lo Habitual"
This was pretty close with "Angel Dust" , but the song "3 Days" gives it the edge. The radio songs just skim the surface and if they are all you have heard you are doing yourself a disservice.
8-Mr Bungle- S/T
If it was not for this album " Angel Dust" would have never come about.Mike Patton never sounded better.
7-Radiohead- "Ok Computer"
"Kid A" is a close second, but this one sounds good even if I was not on drugs at the time, though when this album came out those moments were few and far between. Yorke's voice is great , but at the end of the day its about the songs and they stand the test of time for sure.
6-Tool- "Aenima"
When this album came out it was played at least once a day, any one who was getting stoned to me in the mid 90s will attest to this. This was more of Tool vs Tool , and this beat out "Undertow" because there are more dynamic layers.
5- Type O Negative -"October Rust"
More goth than metal, then layers of this album are amazing, if you are going to get high, then sit between two speaker and listen to this loudly. One of the best produced and written albums ever. Peter Steele's voice also had more depth and passion.
4 - Swans- "Love of Life"
This beat Tool out, because the songs don't take you back to when the album came or feel hampered by how the perception of heavy changes over time, Tool was great, but doesn't seem all that heavy anymore, these guys invoke the same feeling of awe every time played.
3- Morrissey - "Vauxhall & I "
This album came close to being almost as good as The Smiths. If you accept Moz on his own two feet then this is without a doubt some of his best singing and songwriting.
2- Cocteau Twins- " Heaven or Las Vegas"
Heaven should be in this album's title because that is what it sounds like, really the almost 80s drum sound which you almost don't notice once Elizabeth starts singing, is the only thing that gave the number slot the edge as they are not confined to any passage in time.
1- Dead Can Dance- "Into the Labyrinth"
These guys are their only competition, so by process of elimination "A Passage in Time" is a compilation and this album is better than "Spirit Chaser". These songs defy time, they could have come out two hundred years ago , and some did or 200 years in the future and it doesn't matter they just happened to have been released in the 90s when this project was at it's peak.
Thursday, August 20, 2015
The Top 100 albums of the 90s :40 to 31
Ok here we go, you know the deal. We do not give a fuck about what album sold what or if it was on Mtv or not, we care about what has stood the taste of time.
40-Only Living Witness -"Innocents"
The best post-hardcore band you never heard. Their singer can actually sing his ass off and their song have hooks and are in your face. Jonah would later lend his voice to a Converge song.Their drummer who also wrote most of their songs died in 2011 which was several years after the band had broken up.
39- I Mother Earth - "Scenery and Fish"
This Canadian band was often written off as Jane's Addiction wanna-bes, due to the trippy sonic nature of their music and the singer's high raspy and heavily effected vocals on their first album. Their second was huge step forward in terms of songwriting for the band. The band had a strong cult following, by those in the know.
38- Porno For Pyros "s/t"
Perry Ferrel's post Janes band. Steven Perkins was also on board. The first album had more rock to it. People always think of the song "Pets" which garnered the most radio play, but it was "Cursed Female" that had the most sleaze ridden drug fueled passion to it and that is what we wanted from music out of this decade.
37- Sound Garden -Badmotorfinger
Why is Soundgarden so low you ask? Well this album is arguably better than "Superunkown" which despite a few darker moments was another steps towards a more commercial direction. When I first got this album I threw the tap out of the window because I thought the guitar playing sounded too much like Van Halen. It took it a minute to grow on me.
36-Danzig - "Lucifuge"
Yes the first album is better but it came out in the 80s. This one was coated in blues and had a more rock n roll feel to it, despite the fact that all the metal kids ate it up when it was released. Another album that grew on me over time.
35-Acid Bath-"When the Kite String Pops" These New Orleans sludge legends are one of the few bands who is able to appear on this list twice, because their shit is so good it can not be denied.
34-Ben Folds Five -"Whatever and Ever Amen"
One of the best post -Elton John pianists who can also write a mean pop song. Moody and cynical, the ballads are honestyly emoitve. Ben Folds might not be Freddie Mercury , but he knows how to use his voice.
33-Kyuss - "Welcome to Sky Valley"
The band most modern sludge and stoner rock bands owe big time. Pre- Queens of the Stoneage Josh Homme, his fuzzy desert guitar sound was in full effect for this album. The soulful vocals of John Garcia were one of a kind.
32-Tool- "Undertow"
Now we are well into the albums that you can get endless listens out of. Very tense with sinewy guitar slithering through the labyrinth the bass line weaves under Maynard's sensitive drill Sargent approach. The songs are all very tight and well written but get beaten out by another one of the band's albums."I have found some kind of temporary sanity from this shit , blood and cum on my hands."
31- Depeche Mode - "Violator"
This one hardly needs an explanation and perhaps it should even rank higher. This was my I have been up all night on drugs and now I am watching the sun rise album.
Wednesday, December 11, 2013
The Top 100 Greatest Metal Albums: 30 to 21
The most metal of all the hair metal albums. Anthems of the 80's.
29- This is Spinal Tap Soundtrack
While a brilliant parody, they also made some great songs by mistake.
28-Solitude Aeturnus- Through The Darkest Hour
Epic doom with soaring vocals, the song are catchier than you would expect from a band this ominous.
27-Angkor Wat-Corpus Christi
Members of this band would eventual populate the ranks of Nine Inch Nails, this album saw the industrial elements begin of sprout from the the Texas thrash.
26-Ministry-Filth Pig
Other albums might have sold better, but this is the densest and ugliest , which are the elements making this one inarguably metal.
25-Godflesh -Street Cleaner
This album came out in 1989 so to say it is way ahead of it's time is an understatement, considering the influence it has had on bands today.
24-Rainbow- Long Live Rock n Roll
This seemed less like a Ritchie Blackmore solo project and more like it's own concept that stood against any Deep Purple album and Dio's voice shines like a rainbow in the dark.
23-Killing Joke-Pandemonium
After influencing the industrial genre Killing Joke came back in 1994 to reclaim their crown and make one of their heaviest if not best albums to date.
22-Tool- Ænima
At one time this album might have made it to the top ten but over the years as the bar gets set higher for heavy, this power of this album wanes, yet the songs are still great.
21-Deep Purple- In Rock
Ritchie Blackmore blisters on this album, which takes hard hitting blues jams and blows them up to epic proportions for Ian Gillan to have some of his finest moments on.
Tuesday, September 6, 2011
Opeth - Heritage
The jam band element often brings me to expect a " hello bonnaroo " in-between songs, the muscle in the bass playing keeps it from gong into total phish territory, the swing and groove to most songs overshadows the darker elements which were prevalent in Opeth's music almost making the first half of the album too happy for me, the last few songs it begins to darken. The rhythm section shines here, the drumming and bass playing take center in a way not unlike King Crimson or Tool. Fans of the Damnation album will feel comfortable with this one and love the acoustic intervals , but if you are looking for another " your arms my hearse" uh ...not so much . since it is so well done i don't think this is going to get the same kinda reaction Morbid Angel received and they will either lose more of their metal base and pick up the jam kids who where on the fence with them.









.jpg)










