Pages

Tuesday, May 1, 2018

The Top 50 Metal Guitarists - 30 to 21



The death of a guitarist I played with turned my thoughts to what makes a good guitarist great. Metal finds the stakes for guitarists high. Shredding can come before playing a fucking song. While all of these guitarists can play a solo, I was also looking for tone, impact on the genre as a whole and how their personalities came through in their playing. So this list of the top 50 Metal Guitarists. If you don't find your favorite guitar player here then know they were just wankers.


30-Galder

Known for theatrical performances , his tight playing style and clean picking always finds the melody to compensate for the rough vocals. His band has so much going on that over playing would be a detriment.


 


29-Gunter Schulz 

 The best industrial player, as he can pull out thrash riffs as solid as anyone's and color them with the kinds of melodic embellishments needed to give the vocals the back drop they need. Playing with as many electronic elements as he does , you can set you clock to this guys playing. He is a machine.

 

28-Shinichi Ishikawa

 Playing in what became like a black metal version of Mr. Bungle, Shinichi's playing ranged from a more classic rock n roll to lots of wild Hungarian minor scales. He added a human component in his playing to what would otherwise turned into a chaotic circus of wild gymnastics.

 


27-Christian Hector 

Funeral doom can sometimes focus more on the atmosphere than the chops, though a great guitarist can always breathe life into a song despite the trappings of a genre and work within those to still shine. Hector is a prime example of this. He can fire out a solo with enough tasteful shred in it to satisfy any moody metal head. It's his almost jazz like approach that is the most appealing part of his playing.


  
26-Bill Hayden 

 This guy came out of the trash scene inn the late 80s early 90s but his playing was way ahead of it's time, much like his band. His solos retained the dark mood of the songs and were full of melodies , I can sing them all in my head. Then the singer died and never heard from him again.

 


25-Sami Duet

His dark and dynamic playing was more impressive to me in his first band than this current band. He does however prove himself to be just a capable playing blackened death metal as he was swamp sludge that was haunted by the ghost of the Doors. The few solos on those his early work had a rock n roll slant and a touch of wah.


 


24-Marty Friedman


His playing pretty much made the "Rust In Peace" album. He blended all the neo classical non-sense that Yngwie did into something more fluid that worked better in a metal context, than just using boring 80's gallops. Granted he had Dave Mustaine to work off of.


 


23- Juuso Heikkilä


 The thing I like about depressive black metal is the range of emotion. His playing embodies this. He remains tasteful at all times even when his solos go from delicate melodies to ripping your face off, in a band who dynamics is their stock and trade he honors this and is always a part of the song writing process rather than just seeing the song as something that bookends a guitar solo.

    

22-Brent Hinds

Next time I run into Brent he will probably say "Hey man what's up? How's your daughter, we need to jam again sometime, listen man if you weren't so big I would slap you up side your head for putting me on a god damn metal list. Yeah... I know we listened to a bunch of Dio that night I did cocaine off your ferret's cage, but I am a blues guitarist from Alabama. I'm not like those dudes in Meshuggah." But his band put out metal albums and he plays well so here he is. He made it this high because he has a unique finger picking style.

 

21- Paul Masvidal 

 He used to play in a death metal band, but they gradually got more progressive until their music can now summon elves from the future. Listen to the song below and then if you think he doesn't belong where he is then you do not know anything about anything so who cares what you think about this list or any other subject.


 

Monday, April 30, 2018

Looking Back In Anger at Tool's "Undertow"






Continuing to listen back to Tool's catalog and see how it holds up in this case 25 years later. The timing of the band's first full length couldn't have been more perfect. Grunge had set the stage for something this dark and dense. Aside from Maynard's vocals the tight maze like winding of the riffs almost sound like a different band than the one that played on the e.p. Maynard's vocals go right along with the tension they are weaving behind him. Sonically this is like collision of early Swans with King Crimson. More groove than math the chanted vocal swells pummel you with tribal intensity. The bass sounds incredible. Paul D' Amour has a more growling tone than the more progged out groove that the band would eventually churn out. "Intolerance" is a perfect song and the same could be said for the more introspective victim anthem "Prison Sex". Here the groove slithers more fluidly and lends itself to a more crooned melody from Keenan. "Release in sodomy/ for one sweet moment/ I am home" are not lyrics you could find on another metal album up to this point, even Judas Priest' homo eroticism was veiled in thicker metaphor.

The abstract lyrics painted a picture of the dark struggles one suspected was in Maynard's head. These were shrouded in the kind of mystery that would continue to make the band an enigma. The introspective musings of "Sober" have a good dose of self loathing to go with the infectious pulse of the bass driving the song. Maynard's vocal performance here might be the album's most passionate. One of the rare occasions where the album's radio single was not pandering to the lowest common denominator. The self loathing continues on the tighter grooves of "Bottom" until Henry Rollins comes in for the self help seminar crammed into a few bars.  Their is more complicated resentments being processed on  "Crawl Away" which in the wake of nu-metal that followed might seem like more angst ridden metal fodder, but felt fresh when this was released and might not strike me as the album's most inspired lyrics listening back to this, but the riffs compensate for this. The bass playing continues to be incredible, and while Danny Carey has gone onto be known as one of the genre's best drummers, some of that is due to the fact he has had some hellacious bass players to keep up with. His double bass on this songs is pretty tasteful , though aside from the first ep, some of his most straight up metal playing .

The groove and mood to this song still reminds me a little of "Louder Than Love" era Sound Garden. The effects are really well applied to the vocals on this song and help to create the distinct sound we now think of as Maynard. Adam Jones also needs to get a little credit for easing into some more atmospheric moments to give a dynamic shift. The lyrics to the title track begin to paint a murky veil of metaphor and glances at the fact Maynard can really sing with varied dynamics. The drums also get more bombastic in their dynamics as well. This song also has a few moments that certainly seemed really heavy for when this came out, while this might now measure up against Meshuggah, I think the vocal melodies are creative enough to compensate for this. The more homo-erotic hints begins to re-surface in the lyrics to "4 Degrees" .  The song has a more sensuous throb to it.  "Flood" has a more sludge like atmosphere to the ominous pound it lurches out of .It's impressive how they come out of this four and a half minute drone with the groove of this one, it's a outstanding display of dynamics and Maynard delivers his best vocal performance of the album.  They end the album with a wild turn into the more experimental "Disgustipated" which finds the bulk of the song working of the chant of "this is necessary / life feeds on life" . Listening back you can hear the Godflesh / Swans influence on this part.

Overall this finds the band fully realizing their vision, so their only competition is going to become themselves as their influences become more obscured by their progressive leaning. I think this album finds them at their darkest and most tense, two of the things I look for in music, done very well, so this obviously gets a 10.

Sunday, April 29, 2018

Looking Back in Anger at Tool's "Opiate"

With a supposed new album coming out this year. It begs the questions like...does anyone care? ...are they even relevant in today's musical climate, leading to ask "How well have those albums held up in the first place?" Now that is precisely the kind of thing I answer in the Looking Back in Anger column, so I am taking their first ep off it's pedestal to give it a critical listen. When this came out it was heavier at the time than it is now. I could tell that on "Sweat" the first song that bore the ghosts from the 90s in it's production. The picture the lyrics paint were strong enough to compensate for any elements that struggled to drag it out of the 90s. "Hush" is much less interesting on a lyrical level , though more aggressive. The bass playing on this song stands out more, though I do not feel it's as strong of song as "Sweat".

There is a stiffer militant anger to "Part of Me". The tightly chugged riff is a prophetic glance at what was to come on "Undertow". Danny Carey's drumming was not as nuanced as it would become on "Undertow". The taunt guitars are actually the song's strong suit, as Maynard's vocals hand really close to the riff. He does display a strong sense of dynamics, and though it's not his best performance on this album , it is more nuanced than the first two songs. Then comes the two live songs. "Cold & Ugly" reminds me of what my high-school girl friend said to me when she brought this album home from the radio station she worked at. "You'll like these guys they are like a more metal version of Soundgarden. I can hear the grunged out sinew pulsing on this song. Of the two songs "Jerk Off" is more like the sound they would further cultivate. Maynard's vocals are more melodic. Danny Carey also begins to really step up his playing on this as well. Not sure how a lyric like "maybe I should play god/ and shoot you myself" would sit with the p/c police.

Of all the songs the title track holds up the best against the band's current body of work. The vocals are the most melodically sung, and lyrically the stab at religion is well done. The production is a little dated in a few places earlier on in the album so I will give this one a 9.5 , it's more straight forward on a metallic manner which sometimes gives it more of a stiffness than the serpentine groove to come on future albums.

Cold Cave : "You & Me & Infinity"






Wesley is back with the second ep since 2011's "Cherish the Light Years " was released.  Things have change since then and the dark wave dance anthems we found seven years ago on that full length have given way to something with a more stark outlook. The vocals feel darker and have more of a traditional goth croon. Musically it's also not as upbeat and dancey. This is fine with me. Lyrically the romance gone wrong theme is far from new, I think the dry bleak delivery is the strength of the song mood wise. The doubled up vocals grow more desperate on "Nothing is True But You", yet side from the droning synth grows more generic. Musically hings get happier with the peppy on the song "Glory". The beat  reminds me of "Just Can't Get Enough" . It's the vocals that save this one for me and turn the mood around . Their is a depth of feeling in them. The melody is not unlike something Gary Numan might do, but delivered in a lower baritone with a brooding maturity that elevates beyond the average future pop.


The synths are darker in the pulse of "My Heart is Immortal". The vocals provide a more dystopian narrative . The futuristic movement of the beat falls somewhere between the 80s chic of "Stranger Things" and "Tron" or "Blade Runner".  The sparse female vocals that double his voice are nice touches and the passing buzz of noise provides a swathe of abrasion. I have considered if this is just something he wanted to put out so he would have something to go on tour for, but the sound of these songs is a logical progression and keeps up with where this sort of thing is heading. I'll give this a 9. I don't think it's perfect as the drone keeps things dynamically flat in a very robotic sense. I think this is a success in terms of what they set out to do and how he is meeting the expectations of his fan base. So this is very consistent. I hope this doesn't mean I am going to be forced to wait another 7 years for new music from this project as they would lose me at that point point.


Saturday, April 28, 2018

Baptists : "Beacon of Faith"






Canadian sludge punks Baptists are back. The first two songs are more punk in form as they are under two minutes. The first more original in what they are trying to do though it doesn't feel like a fully fleshed out concept and the second song is more formed but sounds like feral distorted punk, which is what they are going for but begs the question...what are they doing that we have not already heard hundreds of other hardcore bands do ? Converge would be the first who comes to mind that fills this need for me personally and they do with more darkness and sonic intensity. So by the time I get to the title track I find myself asking what do I need this band for ?  There is not a resounding answer. There is a little more roar to the drive of "Gift Taker", but nothing that sets this apart from other bands doing similar, as from the aggressive density which they pursue this.

"Capsule" is the first song that breaks the two minute mark. The first minute is pretty much build. There is a more powerful almost Jesus Lizard that rumble to the stomp they finally settle on. There is a more musical quality to the tension created here that makes it the first song to really grip me. "Outbreeding" finds them rushing back into a more furious hard core take on punk that comes fully equipped with gang vocals. They pursue this further in a more Converge like direction with "Vicarious Trauma". The guitars are more interesting the anger in the assault unleashed here is something I have already heard Converge do better. They do implement some interesting elements of atmosphere on this one which is an improvement.

The angular jerk of riff to " Victim Services" keeps their momentum, but the vocal really begin to feel like a one trick pony here. "Indigo Child" keeps the rabid attack going for the throat. But this kind of single minded offense is one your ears are quick to throw up a defense against. The more melodic passage this evolves carries over into "Eulogy Template" that follows. This gives them more breathing room to prove what their guitars are truly capable of. The vocals can't really do much more than what you have already heard from them.The last couple songs are just marginally more refined versions of the same kinda mad dog metallic hardcore these guys are normally banging out this time the production is just better on this album. They can polish this sound they have and are good at what they do so I will give them a 7 as they accomplished what they set out to do , I just already own albums that meet that need. This album comes out May 26th on Southern Lord.


Tuesday, April 24, 2018

The Top 50 Metal Guitarists - 40 to 31





The death of a guitarist I played with turned my thoughts to what makes a good guitarist great. Metal finds the stakes for guitarists high. Shredding can come before playing a fucking song. While all of these guitarists can play a solo, I was also looking for tone, impact on the genre as a whole and how their personalities came through in their playing. So this list of the top 50 Metal Guitarists. If you don't find your favorite guitar player here then know they were just wankers.


40-Joey Z

How memorable is your work? Joey would answer very, which is why he is hanging tough along side guitarists who might be more technically sound. He is like the hard core little brother of Kirk Hammett the way he works cool melody lines into their riffs.


39-Eyal Levi

The problem with most death metal that makes it not worth a second listen is the guitarists all go for maximum speed and density, think being influenced by Slayer instead of Incantation is expanding their horizons, and play variations of the solos found on "Altars of Madness" . Eyal did not follow the status quo in that regard. He brought a hooky sense of groove to his band and layered it with neo-classical musicality that did not demand a pirate shirt to be worn.



38-Vivian Campbell 

He plays on the first 3 Dio albums...end of story


36-Chris De Garmo

There was once a awesome band who lost their guitarist who crafted their best work, then became a variation of Spinal Tap.



35-Bill Steer 

Helped create grind core. Napalm Death brought the more spastic elements, while his band brought the more gore ridden death metal elements to it. The riffs are so mean they would eat you if he was not a vegetarian.He proves brutality and melody can co-exist.





34 William Wright Barrow

This British gent brings a dignified and progressive quality to his band's brand of black metal that almost makes it steam punk in the nuanced Victorian quirk it possesses , so to make sounds that are visual is a feat. 




 33-Devin Townsend 

Got his start playing with Steve Vai. He then thought he could keep up with the drummer from Dark Angel. His various projects have covered a broad expanse some more metal than others. He has a distinct tone.


32-Peter Lindgren

He originally joined the band as a bass player and switched to guitar. As his band's vocals shifted their focus and added melody he augmented his playing to do the same incorporating a David Gilmore like sense for less is more.

< 

31-Greg Chandler 

He brought a degree of musicality to funeral doom that has been rarely rivaled in the genre. This tone grasps the kind of despair needed. He paints sonic picture rather than just overpowering you with a wall of feed back and distortion.


 

Monday, April 23, 2018

Sleep : "the Sciences"


Now that the smoke cleared from 4-20 we can now take a look at the first album in two decades from Sleep. If you are new to stoner metal and just crawling out from under a mushroom, then you might know guitarist Matt Pike from this other band called High On Fire. Al Cisneros who handles the vocals has also played in OM and this time they have the drummer from Neurosis sitting behind the drums. I'll go ahead and warn you that the first song is just feed back and distortion and not really a song at all, though it might scare you. However they have been kind enough buds to let you known when it's safe to listen by including the sound of a water bong being fired up. The vocals come across a little different than I remember. They are lower and not as soaked in effects.

I think  Jason Roeder's playing sparks new life into their overall sound. The lumbering thunder stirred up make "Sonic Titan" a fitting name for the song. I prefer the grooving movement of " Marijuanauts Theme", but if you are into stoner doom then this is the kind of volume intensive battery you are looking. The bass tone is thick and nasty as it should be, with fuzz coating your brain with every note. They wait for six minutes to bring in the vocals on "Sonic Titan" so have retained the jam like quality their brand of bong worshiping lends itself to.The album is produced in a way that begs to be played at maximum volume. It does have a dynamic ebb and flow as "Antarcticans Thawed" begins in a more subtle fashion with room to breathe in the chilly vibe. Four minutes into the song and it's not to bob your head along.

The albums  third act finds their slow incorporation of melodic embellishments beginning to peak. "Giza Butler" has a more sinewy slither to it's narcotic pulse. It's rides on this until builds up to gallop across the desert in the last minute. If you are into guitar solos "The Botanist" puts a David Gilmore like blazer into the spotlight. Matt Pike has become a better guitarist over the years and this will only push his status as such further into consciousness of the general metal populous. Is this worth a two decade wait ? Is anything ? It does a good job of picking up where they left off. With these guys older and wiser the results doesn't come short of them proving themselves capable of sitting along side the like of Kyuss in the smoky halls of stoner metal royalty. I'll give this one a 9 and see how it sits with me though due to the rambling length of the songs I am not sure how much air time this will get .